Mayor of Minneapolis

Does Jacob Frey have the interest of the people, or of himself?

audrey notsch


Politicians are some of the most polarizing people to ever grace the public sphere. Although their purpose is to represent the people, it doesn’t always feel like this is their true intentions. The mayor of Minneapolis, Jacob Frey, is a good example of this. In November of last year, Frey won the mayoral election and succeeded in being reelected for a third term, beating his top competitor Omar Fateh by a little less than 10,000 votes.

Despite being the mayor of Minneapolis for what will be 12 years by the end of his current term, when I asked students here at the University of Minnesota for their opinions on Frey, they were all far from positive.

“I am not a fan [of Frey],” 24-year-old UMN student Melanie Linzbach commented. “At a time where we need forward movement and determinant action, Frey is disappointingly stagnant in almost every decision he makes. He has historically handled major incidents during his mayoral run, poorly—George Floyd, the anti-ICE protests. I’m not saying that it would have been easy for anyone to handle these situations, but he didn’t do them well.”

In January, ICE presence in Minnesota was drastically increasing. Especially in Minneapolis, these agents were regularly enacting violence on Minnesotans—abusing, harassing, harming, and even killing people. Jacob Frey’s public response to what was happening was telling these ICE agents to, “get the fuck out of Minneapolis,” and that these agents’ claims of self-defense were “bullshit.” The issue here is not Frey’s words, but his actions that followed—although his statement was in defense of the people of Minneapolis, it held hollow promise.

While Frey was constantly reiterating how he cares for the people of Minneapolis, how terrible these ICE agents were acting, in the same breath he stated that, “I do not support abolishing ICE.” He did take some actions against ICE, such as banning them from using city-owned parking ramps, lots, and garages. But he is more against the ways in which President Trump is “allowing” these agents to act, rather than disagreeing with the fundamental systems in which ICE works upon. This is why Frey is a good example of a public servant, who doesn’t have the public in mind with his actions—he knows that in order to keep his power as mayor in this political system, he cannot start to dismantle and overtly criticize the parts of the system he is a part of.

“He’s dumb, and NOT a good mayor,” 18-year-old UMN student Molly Pitzen said. “His treatment of unhoused people in Minneapolis has been atrocious.”

Frey has not been shy about his aggressive policy of clearing out homeless encampments, saying that they breed crime and violence. In December of last year, he vetoed an ordinance that would have made it mandatory for the city to provide handwashing stations and portable bathrooms at homeless encampments, and given them at least one week’s notice before planning to clear them out. Frey explained that this ordinance would, “encourage encampments to grow and make it harder for the city to intervene before [these encampments] become a large, established, dangerous one.” He then went on to say that this regulation would “fail the very people it claims to help.”

Frey has made efforts to help the unhoused population through creating more affordable housing and shelters for the houseless. However, these efforts don’t really seem to try and fix homelessness at the root. Like Linzbach said, many of Frey’s efforts ended up being quite stagnant—his efforts are more short-term solutions to a systemic problem. Clearing out these encampments isn’t encouraging these people to seek out more stable shelter, rather, it devoids these people of having any sort of stability to try and help themselves. Providing basic care, like bathrooms and handwashing stations, may seem like it would encourage most of the houseless population to stay at encampments, but it would offer a humane resource for them to be grounded to, and allow them to be safer and healthier.

I am curious how the mayor of such a notoriously “blue” city is continuously re-elected, despite how his legislative actions aren’t seemingly very “liberal” in nature.

“Frey was the establishment democrat,” Linzbach said. “He appealed to older folks, and to folks that weren’t excited about a more leftist perspective, but also didn’t want a truly conservative mayor. He was the comfortable option in a time when a lot of people were (rightfully) scared of the country swinging to the right.”

The demographics of Frey’s voters largely align with Linzbach’s perspective, that “higher socioeconomic status (SES) precincts (meaning those with higher incomes, whiter populations, more homeowners, and higher levels of education) supported incumbent Mayor Frey at higher rates than Omar Fateh.”

This would make sense as to why Frey keeps being re-elected year after year; people who are lower-income have a harder time getting to the polls, as it can be extremely inconvenient for them to access a polling site, or even have the privilege of free time in their day to vote. This means that middle-class and higher income individuals may make up more of the total votes, and if these people tend to lean towards candidates like Frey, they would be more likely to win.

Despite being voted in because of a certain demographic largely favoring him, Frey should be representing all Minneapolis residents. It seems, however, that he is not acting with intentions to favor all. With all that I have shared, it appears that Frey likes to “seem like this ‘beacon of progress,’” which is how Pitzen explained it. Frey will lean towards making decisions based on what will benefit him the most—such as telling ICE to get out of Minneapolis, knowing this will make headlines; but at the same time condoning the existence of ICE as a system and stating he plans to “end homelessness” while failing to show any empathy towards those who are unhoused.

This begs the question, do the people we elect even have our interests in mind? To an extent, I think that they do, especially “smaller” politicians (mayors, governors). At the same time, however, these political figures have a tendency to do what’s best for their approval ratings, or what will help them stay safe in the political sphere. I am interested in what the result will be for the next mayoral race in Minneapolis—there is no term limit for mayors in Minneapolis, so will Frey once again win? Or will Minneapolis residents call for a change in representation?

Wake Mag